Skip to content
Having a backup power source during power outages is crucial, especially for those who rely on electricity for medical devices or live in areas prone to extreme weather. When researching backup power options for your home, two of the most popular choices are portable power stations and standby generators. But which one is the better fit for your needs? In this comprehensive guide, we'll compare portable power stations and standby generators to help you decide which backup power solution is ideal for your home.
What Is a Portable Power Station?
A portable power station is a rechargeable battery pack that can provide power for your electronic devices, small appliances, and limited home needs during blackouts and other emergencies. Portable power stations range from 200 to over 2,000 watts and feature multiple AC outlets, USB charging ports, 12V carports, and sometimes RV sockets.
The lithium-ion batteries in portable power stations hold a charge for months when not in use. They can be recharged by being plugged into a wall outlet at home or via solar panels. The best portable power stations have a power inverter built-in to convert the DC battery power into standard AC electricity used by household electronics and appliances.
Compared to standby whole-house generators, portable power stations are much smaller in size and weight. Quality models have carrying handles or wheels so they can easily be moved around your home or taken with you on camping trips when electricity access is limited.
What Is a Standby Generator?
Unlike portable generators that must be manually started and connected to appliances, a standby generator is permanently installed outside your home and runs on propane or natural gas. It automatically turns on seconds after detecting a power outage from the main electrical grid through an automatic transfer switch.
Standby generators deliver backup power to your home's electrical circuits, allowing essential appliances like refrigerators, freezers, and medical devices to continue running uninterrupted. They come in power outputs between 7kW and 30kW, enough capacity to handle larger appliances, including your home AC system, electric water heater, microwave, and more.
For whole-house coverage, standby generators require professional installation, including connecting to your home's breaker panel and fuel line. Most operate on propane or natural gas with an option for diesel as the fuel source.
The engine and components of a standby generator are housed in weatherproof steel or aluminum casing. They run off the same gasoline combustion engine used in automobiles, just optimized for providing electricity. Standby generators automatically run self-diagnostic tests and exercises to ensure they'll turn on when needed.
Key Differences Between Portable Power Stations and Standby Generators
Now that we've covered the basics of both backup power sources, here's a helpful comparison of the key differences:
- Portability – Portable power stations are compact and lightweight. Standby generators are permanently fixed installations.
- Capacity – Standby generators can power entire homes. Portable stations work for smaller devices and appliances.
- Fuel Source – Portable stations use rechargeable lithium-ion batteries. Standby generators use propane, natural gas, or diesel.
- Ease of Use – Portable stations are plug-and-play. Standby generators require professional installation.
- Noise – Standby generators tend to be louder when running. Portable stations operate very quietly.
- Upfront Cost – Portable power stations are more affordable. Purchasing and installing a standby generator costs thousands.
- Ongoing Costs – Portable stations require occasional battery replacement. Standby generators need fuel and maintenance.
As you can see, portable power stations are better suited for portable use cases like camping or during shorter power failures. Their compact size, silent operation, and lower upfront cost make them accessible to more homeowners. For whole-house backup power that automatically supplies electricity during prolonged outages, a standby generator is worth the higher installation investment. Their larger fuel tanks provide days or even weeks of uninterrupted power.
How to Choose Portable Power Stations vs. Standby Generators?
So, when trying to decide between portable power stations and standby generators, start by realistically evaluating your home's backup power needs:
- What devices/appliances do you want to power during an outage? Make a list of everything you'd want to run off a backup generator. High-energy items like AC units and electric furnaces may push you towards a standby generator. If it's just phones, lights, and a fridge, a portable station may suffice.
- How long might power failures last in your region? Areas prone to multi-day storms with electrical infrastructure damage benefit more from permanently installed standby generators versus portable stations with shorter battery life.
- Do you require medical-grade backup power reliability? For those dependent on medical devices at home, a standby generator's automatic activation provides peace of mind.
- How sensitive are the devices you want to run? Electronics and appliances with tighter voltage requirements operate better on a standby generator's stable power output.
- What is your budget for backup power? The higher upfront cost of a standby generator pays off long-term for whole-house coverage. Portable stations offer more affordable short-term portable power.
- Is professional installation an option? If you cannot or prefer not to have standby generators installed, a plug-and-play portable station is the way to go.
- How important is portability? Do you want to use your backup power source for camping or in multiple locations? Portable stations are designed for maximum mobility.
Once you've weighed the above considerations, you'll have a good sense of whether a portable power station or standby generator better matches your family's needs and budget. For many homeowners, having both can provide comprehensive backup power protection. Use a standby generator for whole-home coverage during prolonged multi-day outages. Have a portable power station as a supplemental source for smaller devices that can be moved around easily.
Conclusion
When comparing portable power stations vs. standby generators, there are clear tradeoffs in terms of power output, fuel sources, mobility, upfront costs, and ease of use. Portable stations excel at providing short-term portable power for smaller devices. Standby generators offer robust whole-home coverage for extended outages but require professional installation. Take time to evaluate your home's backup power requirements and how much you're willing to invest upfront. For complete protection, having both a quality portable power station as well as a permanently installed standby generator provides the best of both worlds. Empower yourself with the right backup power solution for your family's unique needs.
FAQ
- 1. How long do portable power stations last on a full charge?
- Portable power stations last anywhere from a few hours to multiple days on a single charge, depending on the battery capacity, devices powered, and usage. Quality models can be recharged from wall outlets or solar panels in 1-4 hours.
- 2. Do you need a transfer switch for a standby generator?
- Yes, standby generators require a transfer switch installed by an electrician. The switch automatically detects grid power outages and switches to the generator within seconds to power your home's electrical circuits.
- 3. What size standby generator is needed for a whole house?
- For whole-house coverage, a standby generator between 14kW and 22kW is recommended. Size it 30% higher than the required rated watts for your largest motor or appliance. Consult an electrician to properly size a standby generator for your home.
- 4. Are portable power stations allowed on airplanes?
- Yes, most airlines allow portable power stations under 100Wh battery capacity in carry-on bags or checked luggage following lithium-ion battery transportation guidelines. Larger capacity models may be restricted.
- 5. How long do standby generators run on a tank of gas?
- The runtime of a standby generator on a full tank varies based on fuel source and load. However, most can run for 24 hours or longer on a single tank when powering essential appliances and circuits.
